46-47 Johnny Pesky, BOS 52
48-49 Ted Williams, BOS 51
50-51 George Kell, PHA 65
52-53 Mickey Vernon, WAS 40
54-55 Jim Rivera, BAL 41
56-57 Billy Gardner, BOS 47
58-59 Jim Landis, CWS 40
60-61 Al Kaline, DET 45
62-63 Floyd Robinson, WAS 50
64-65 Eddie Bressoud, BAL 41
66-67 Tony Oliva, BOS 38